Sally Port Mess - Stack Arms

The Formula for Progressiveitis
Jeremy Bevard

I was asked to write an article on what makes a c/p/h reenactor. Since everything I know about this topic would come from other sources I was not sure how to do this. Also, what makes me the person to even write this? Most of what I would write is most likely not original ideas or thoughts from me. Most of what I know on what makes a progressive reenactor comes from things I have read in books, online forums, asking questions and seeking answers. I have decided to write something things down in more of a informal blog type format. What is to follow are all things that I have picked up from somewhere, someone, something and then formed my own educated opinion on. In other words, I don’t always know where I picked something up or where the idea came from so don’t expect footnotes or references. I also have taken more of a how to become a c/p/her approach then a what makes a c/p/her. I think one follows the other.
            Now that we have that out of the way I will give some info on who I am. I have been reenacting for about seven years. I spent the first three to four of those years an out right farb. Yes, I am comfortable to now admit that I was a farb. But all of that is for another time. About four years ago I knew I wanted more from the hobby. This is also about the time I found a great resource on the web, The Authentic Campaigner forum. I was having information overload! I slowly started to make improvements to what I was doing and how I was thinking. I have spent the last one-two years taking great strides with improving what I do in this hobby. During this time I also became infected with the upgrading and buying equipment disease. Seriously, there should be an anonymous support group for this. “Hello, my name is Jeremy and I suffer from upgrading-gottahaveit progressiveitis. I recently relapsed when I purchased another issue blanket from an online message board. But no really it is ok because it is better then my other issue blanket and I could really need another because….oh wait this is why I am here. Sorry. Please don’t tell my wife”. So, does any of this make me an authoritative person on what makes a c/p/h reenaactor? No, but I believe I have some answers and opinions and I’m going to give them. Now let’s get started.
            The number one most important part of upgrading your impression comes from your attitude. Forget the gear at least at first. If you can not show up at an event with the right attitude you have nothing, no matter how much you spend. So what is the right attitude? The right attitude to me is walking into an event with the mind set you are going to do your best to represent the soldiers who lived in the time period being portrayed. The right attitude is not worrying that the public or other reenactors will see you as different or not fitting in. Take comfort in knowing you are being as accurate as you can be. Know that you are showing the public what they came there to see. Know that whether you or the other reenactors realize it you are setting an example. The right attitude means changing and improving the things you have control over. You have control over how you personally camp, march, drill, eat, sleep, and what you buy and wear. Here is the catch. To really get the most out of having the right attitude you need to have friends with you who do to, the more the better.
            Alright, so you and your friends have the right attitude. This must mean you want to start upgrading and buying better gear. Where do you start? I’m going to give my formula for buying gear. I’m sure there are lots of varying opinions but this one is mine. It has been developed from all my trial and errors. I wish I could have seen something like this when I started. I’m not going to get into where to buy or what makes a good item. There are other sources for that. I also am not including smaller items such as socks and mess gear. These can be purchase as you go. This formula is also assuming you already have a complete mainstream-sutler row kit.
The first three items I would upgrade would be forage cap, sack coat, and blanket. Why? Because these seem to be the most noticeable when they are wrong. This includes how they look and feel on you. Next I would recommend a canteen, shelter half, and haversack. A bad canteen can also be seen from far off and at times I think the same with a haversack. With a correct blanket and shelter half you can now pack properly for an event with a blanket roll or knapsack. The third round should be a good shirt and trousers. You now have a complete basic uniform. Now start looking for your leathers and an original bayonet. You should wait to upgrade you bayonet scabbard until you have your good bayonet. This way you know they will fit together. Now, start getting the other less essential items. Knapsack, dress hat, spare shirt, brogans, ect.
During this whole process I hope you have been reading and more importantly absorbing what you are reading. Instead of just reading Hardtack and Coffee as if it is just another book read it as if it was written to be your personal how to guide. First hand accounts are a c/pher’s guide and instruction book. To me a big part of the progressive reenactor is researching and learning. With that they should not be afraid to change what they think and how they do things. During this reading, buying and attitude changing time I hope you also learned to forget or at least challenge many of the reeanctorisms that exist. Oh, you want an example? Well haversack stuffers don’t stuff your haversack. They stuff your knapsack, blanket roll and pockets. Your haversack is for food related items. When you carry correct rations you will realize why. Nobody wants their book or image from home damaged by grease, crumbs, and other nasty food crud.
Now we have the gear, are developing the attitude and knowledge what else? Remember your likeminded friends you found? Bond with them. Become pards, comrades, messmates, whatever term you want to use. Learn to work together and trust each other. Preparing your rations or whatever else you have to do is much easier if it is split up between men. This also includes carrying items. Everything you bring should fit on your person and you should be able to wear it most of the day. If you can’t, take a close look at what you’re bringing to an event. A way to help with this is do what they did. You partner up and work with your messmates again. Trust me there is plenty of room in a shelter tent for at least two men, maybe even three. In other words each man gets half a tent.
Now you have all the ground work laid out. Take the next big step and get out of your comfort zone. Remember, being uncomfortable means growth. Register and go to a true c/p/h event. The cost really is minimal as long as you have a day or two of vacation time to take. Any event trip I have gone to seems to cost around $60 for gas and a room with one to two men splitting it. I’m sure you would spend almost that during a weekend at home. Don’t be afraid of the veteran progressives or the event standards. Instead learn from them all. Use the event standards as an opportunity to expand your knowledge and upgrade a piece of gear. The men you meet at the events will be glad to help you and happy to have you. Especially if you have a firm hold of everything talked about above.
Well, I hope I have answered some of the questions that might have been out there which prompted me to write this. If nothing else I assure you that if you follow the formula and guidance written in this you will very soon contract your very own case of upgrading-gottahaveit progressiveitis.

Back